45 Results Found
All Thrift Stores, Secondhand Vintage and Consignment Shop Listings for Reynoldsburg, OH
For details, coupons, ratings, comments, and helpful links, view the store’s profile.
No dressing rooms. Prices are higher than Goodwill but it's better quality merchandise. I think this is a for-profit store and not a charity (Read More)
11.7 mi
5738 Columbus Sq.
Columbus, OH 43231
(614)714-2444
I go here on my lunch break and I have found SO many awesome shirts for work. Like GOOD brand name ones in great shape. And some good vintage items in home decor. The picture frames are WAY too expensive, but I have found killer vintage liquor decanters here. Not a big furniture selection, but the rest is normal and good. (Read More)
12.1 mi
647 Harrisburg Pike
Columbus, OH 43223
(614)272-6281
Be aware that the men's department and children's department are located upstairs with only stair access. (Read More)
12.1 mi
647 Harrisburg Pike
Columbus, OH 43123
(614)272-6281
A bit cluttered, small selection. Quality of items was fairly low but the staff was very nice and I did buy a couple of pieces of costume jewelry for a great price. Limited hours. (Read More)
12.1 mi
4392 Indianola Ave.
Columbus, OH 43214
(614)778-3295
Great little store with cuts of fabric and other crafts. Staff is very nice too :-) (Read More)
13.1 mi
4768 N. High St.
Columbus, OH 43214
(614)261-7377
They used to take consignments but no more. Now a donations-only shop. The prices have really gone up lately. (Read More)
13.1 mi
1944 W. 1st Ave.
Columbus, OH 43212
(614)488-6564
I used to LOVE shopping this store when it was on Indianola - it had lots of fun stuff at good prices. Since they moved and have tried to turn into more of a "boutique" type store, I've walked out empty handed every time, except when they were having a 75% off sale. The prices are just too high. The selection seems to be less too - I don't know if they are rejecting more things to maintain their "boutique" feel, or if they are pulling things to list online, or what... I heard one of the workers discussing how they "need to get the word out" about the store, to try to drum up business - I wanted to take her aside and tell her the new pricing is the problem! The lack of selection is the problem! The "boutique" is the problem! So frustrating... :( (Read More)
13.3 mi
1005 Mediterranean Ave.
Columbus, OH 43229
(614)565-1306
13.8 mi
5600 N. High St.
Worthington, OH 43085
(614)848-8408
This store has better prices than Ohio Thrift. The toy section is kinda scarce as is the kid's section. However they do have dressing rooms! (Read More)
14.1 mi
4026 McDowell Ave.
Grove City, OH 43123
(614)801-1625
Don't expect to get all your merchandise back if it doesn't sell. It mysteriously vanishes and cannot be found anywhere in the store. Very disappointing if it is something you would like back. (Read More)
14.2 mi
3684 Garden Ct.
Grove City, OH 43123
(614)871-1126
This is now my new go to resale shop. I wish they had more of a selection however the quality out shined the quantity. The staff was wonderful and I can't wait to return. (Read More)
14.3 mi
1198 Kenny Centre Mall
Columbus, OH 43220
(614)457-4227
Too many " new " store return items that are junk and too high on prices. It's supposed to be a thrift store and not a retail store. (Read More)
14.4 mi
715 W. Coshocton St.
Johnstown, OH 43031
(740)967-2926
14.6 mi
7107 Northgate Way
Westerville, OH 43082
(614)523-4100
14.7 mi
240 N. Wilson Rd.
Columbus, OH 43204
(614)737-8673
15 mi
3060 Southwest Blvd.
Grove City, OH 43123
(614)820-2324
