I thought I was the only one with that tic!!
I can often be seen in outfits which, taken together, should have cost $250 or more. When I receive a compliment, which is fairly often, I simply cannot resist replying that the entire ensemble (blouse, skirt, and shoes) cost a grand total of $12.
re: the pitchman angle. I started taking a male friend on my thrift runs, and he started putting together a cheapo thrift wardrobe. At the time, he was working for the Ford modeling agency (i.e. Fashion Ground Zero), and his fashionista co-workers kept asking where he found the awesome stuff he wore.
Most people are a tough sell, and I think they see thrift stores as being only for the indigent and clueless.
www.fullservicebohemian.blogspot.com